Court refuses challenge to NHS Tayside’s approach to adult ADHD assessments

The Court of Session has refused a petition challenging NHS Tayside’s approach to assessing adults with suspected ADHD who do not have a co-occurring mental health condition. The full judgment is available on the Scottish Courts website here: https://www.scotcourts.gov.uk/media/yxwc2n4q/2026csoh112-michael-howe-for-judicial-review.pdf

Govan Law Centre (GLC) acted for Michael Howe, whose GP referred him for an ADHD assessment after he moved to Tayside in 2023. He had previously been referred by a GP in England in 2019. No assessment had taken place when the court considered his case.

The petition argued that NHS Tayside had adopted a policy around 2021 which effectively excluded patients with ADHD-only symptoms from assessment by placing them on a static waiting list. It challenged the lawfulness of that practice, including on equality, consultation and reasonable-adjustment grounds.

In her Opinion, Lady Hood preferred the health board’s evidence that its underlying approach had not changed. Referrals continued to be accepted and classified as routine, but higher-priority mental health cases consumed most available capacity. She accepted that a separate waiting list introduced around 2021 was an administrative measure rather than a new policy.

The court accepted that increased demand nationally and locally had overwhelmed existing arrangements. It also accepted evidence about staffing shortages, the time required for ADHD assessments and risks to other patients if resources were diverted. Lady Hood acknowledged that patients in Mr Howe’s position might not be assessed, or might face a long wait.

The court rejected the statutory-duty, irrationality and discrimination challenges, as well as the claims concerning reasonable adjustments, equality impact assessment and consultation. Questions of expenses were reserved.

Rachel Moon, GLC Firm Partner and instructing solicitor in the petition, said: “Our client primarily lost on the facts as the Court did not accept that NHS Tayside adopted a new policy from 2021, resulting in very few if any patients being assessed for ADHD in Perth over the last several years.

“The Lord Ordinary (para 18) preferred the health board’s explanation that what changed from 2021 was an increase in demand nationally and locally for ADHD assessments. Unfortunately, this analysis failed to properly explain or provide a justification for why very few patients in Perth have ever been treated for ADHD over many years.

“From the petitioner’s perspective, it would seem that NHS Tayside cannot be held to account for its systemic and abject failure to provide assessments for patients with a GP ADHD referral in Scotland’s courts. That is most unfortunate for the many thousands of patients in Scotland seeking treatment for ADHD”.

Call Now Button